The Platform Engineer's Guide to Internal Component Management

Last Reviewed

May 9, 2025

Internal software modules—libraries, services, templates—are the building blocks of modern applications. When managed well, they accelerate development, ensure consistency, and improve reliability. But left untamed, they can quickly become a dense jungle: hard-to-find components, confusing duplicates, outdated dependencies, and unclear ownership. This proliferation leads to developer frustration, wasted effort, and slower delivery cycles. Platform engineers sit at the heart of managing this ecosystem. This guide provides practical strategies and concrete examples for navigating the internal module lifecycle, from establishing standards and governance to improving discoverability, documentation, versioning, consolidation, and deprecation, ultimately fostering a healthier and more productive development environment.

1. Standardization and Governance: Paving the Golden Paths

Standardization is the bedrock of an efficient platform. It involves defining and promoting approved ways of building and deploying software, often using vetted internal modules and tools. This consistency reduces complexity, accelerates developer onboarding, simplifies maintenance, enhances stability, and bolsters security.¹ For developers, standardization translates directly into reduced cognitive load and streamlined workflows, freeing them up to focus on business logic rather than wrestling with infrastructure or reinventing common patterns.¹

1.1. Selecting Standard Modules: Making Informed Choices

When multiple internal modules exist for the same purpose (a common symptom of organic growth or past mergers), the platform team must establish a process for selecting the official, standard offering. This process shouldn't be arbitrary; it requires a structured approach:

Define the Business Case: Articulate why standardization is needed for this specific functionality (e.g., reduce maintenance cost, improve security, provide consistent features).⁸
Gather Requirements: Collaboratively define the essential features and non-functional requirements (performance, security, scalability) the standard module must meet. Involve developers who will use the module.⁸
Identify Candidates: List the existing internal modules that potentially meet the requirements.⁹
Evaluate Options: Assess each candidate against the defined criteria. Demos and pilot tests can be valuable here.⁸
Make the Decision: Use a structured method, like a decision matrix, to objectively compare the candidates and select the standard.⁸

A Decision Matrix helps quantify the evaluation process. List the criteria, assign weights based on importance, score each candidate module against each criterion, and calculate a weighted total score.¹⁰

A structured evaluation helps justify the choice and ensures the selected module best aligns with both technical needs and organizational priorities.¹⁰

1.2. Golden Paths: The Paved Road for Developers

Once standard modules and tools are chosen, "Golden Paths" provide developers with an opinionated, supported, and well-documented way to use them for common tasks, like creating a new microservice or deploying a web application. A Golden Path isn't just documentation; it typically includes concrete assets ¹⁹:

Repository Template: A starter project with standard structure, configuration files, and basic "hello world" functionality.
Standard CI/CD Pipeline: A pre-configured pipeline that builds, tests (including security scans and standard module checks), and deploys the application according to organizational best practices.
Deployment Manifests: Standardized Helm charts, Kustomize overlays, or Terraform configurations for deploying the application.
Baked-in Observability: Default configurations for logging, metrics, and tracing integrated with the platform's observability stack.

These paths are often implemented using scaffolding tools integrated into the Internal Developer Platform (IDP), such as the Backstage Software Scaffolder or custom CLIs. These tools guide developers through a series of questions and automatically generate the project structure, CI/CD configuration, and initial code based on the Golden Path template.

YAML


# Example Backstage Scaffolder Snippet (Conceptual)
apiVersion: scaffolder.backstage.io/v1beta3
kind: Template
metadata:
  name: golden-path-service-template
  title: Golden Path Backend Service
  description: Creates a standardized backend service using approved modules and CI/CD pipeline.
spec:
  owner: platform-team
  type: service
  parameters:
    - title: Service Details
      required: [name, owner]
      properties:
        name:
          title: Service Name
          type: string
          description: Unique name for the service (e.g., user-auth-service)
        owner:
          title: Owner Team
          type: string
          ui:field: OwnerPicker
          ui:options:
            catalogFilter: { kind: Group }
    #... other parameters like repo location...
  steps:
    - id: fetch-template
      name: Fetch Base Template
      action: fetch:template
      input:
        url:./skeleton # Path to the template skeleton directory
        values:
          name: ${{ parameters.name }}
          owner: ${{ parameters.owner }}
          #... other template values...
    - id: publish
      name: Publish to Source Control
      action: publish:github # Or other SCM
      input:
        #... repo details based on parameters...
    - id: register
      name: Register Catalog Component
      action: catalog:register
      input:
        #... catalog info details...
    #... potentially add CI/CD setup steps...

Crucially, Golden Paths achieve adoption through value, not mandate. They must be optional, allowing developers to deviate for specific needs or innovation. They need to be transparent, so developers can understand what's happening under the hood and build trust. They should be extensible, allowing teams to add specific steps or configurations without breaking the core path. And they need to be customizable through parameters to fit different contexts.¹⁹ When the Golden Path is the easiest, fastest, and most reliable way to get compliant code into production, developers will choose it willingly, reducing the need for rigid enforcement and avoiding the proliferation of "shadow IT".

1.3. Governance Strategies: Beyond Gatekeeping

Effective platform governance shifts the operations role from being a gatekeeper (manually approving every change) to an enabler (building guardrails and automated checks into the platform).²¹ This is essential for scaling operations and improving developer velocity.

Preventing Module Proliferation: Uncontrolled creation of similar modules is a common problem. Governance strategies to combat this include:

Visibility: Using the service catalog (see Section 3) to make existing modules easily discoverable.²³
Standardization: Promoting the use of approved modules through Golden Paths and clear documentation.³
Automation: Embedding checks in CI/CD pipelines to detect the use of non-standard or duplicate modules.²⁵
Policy-as-Code: Using tools like Open Policy Agent (OPA) to enforce rules about module usage during infrastructure provisioning.
Organizational Alignment: Addressing root causes like poor cross-team communication or lack of awareness about existing solutions.²⁶

Enforcing Standards with Policy-as-Code (OPA): Tools like OPA allow platform teams to define infrastructure policies as code (using the Rego language) and automatically enforce them. For example, a policy can check Terraform plans to ensure only approved, standard modules are being used.

# Example OPA Policy (Rego) for Terraform Module Governance
package terraform.module_governance

# Define the set of approved module sources
# Adjust paths based on your Terraform Registry, Git repo, etc.
approved_module_sources := {
  "terraform-aws-modules/vpc/aws",
  "app.terraform.io/my-org/modules/standard-db/aws",
  "git::https://internal-git.example.com/tf-modules/secure-bucket.git"
}

# Deny rule: trigger if a 'create' action uses a module source not in the approved list
deny[msg] {
  # Iterate through resource changes in the input plan
  module_call := input.resource_changes[_]
  # Check if the resource type is 'module'
  module_call.type == "module"
  # Check if the action is 'create' (ignore updates/deletes for this check)
  module_call.change.actions[_] == "create"
  # Check if the module's source address is NOT in the approved set
  not approved_module_sources[module_call.module_address]

  # Construct the denial message
  msg := sprintf(
    "Module '%s' source '%s' is not an approved standard module. Please use modules from the approved list.",
    [module_call.address, module_call.module_address]
  )
}

# --- Optional: Deny specific non-standard modules by source ---
# deny[msg] {
#   module_call := input.resource_changes[_]
#   module_call.type == "module"
#   module_call.module_address == "some/non-standard/module/source" # Specify the exact source to block
#   msg := "Usage of the non-standard module 'some/non-standard/module/source' is prohibited. Please use an approved alternative."
# }

Code Explanation: This Rego policy defines a set approved_module_sources. The deny rule checks each resource change in the Terraform plan (input). If a resource is a module being created (actions[_] == "create") and its source (module_call.module_address) is not found within the approved_module_sources set, the rule triggers, generating an error message (msg) that specifies the non-compliant module. This policy can be evaluated against a Terraform plan JSON output to automatically block deployments using unapproved modules.²⁸

Implementing such governance requires buy-in across development, operations, and security teams, as platform standards impact everyone.³ Strong commitment from management is crucial to provide the necessary resources and authority to establish and enforce these standards effectively. Governance should be viewed as a strategic enabler that improves speed, security, and reliability, rather than a bureaucratic hurdle.

2. Making Modules Findable: The Discoverability Imperative

A common developer pain point is simply finding the right internal module or understanding if one even exists for a specific task.³⁰ Poor visibility leads to wasted time searching, frustration, and the unintentional duplication of effort when developers rebuild functionality that already exists elsewhere in the organization.²³ Lack of awareness about existing components is a primary driver of redundant modules.²³

2.1. The Role of the Service Catalog (e.g., Backstage)

An automated service catalog, often implemented as part of an Internal Developer Platform (IDP) like Backstage, serves as the central, searchable inventory for all software components—services, libraries, websites, templates, APIs, resources, and more. It acts as a single source of truth, providing visibility into the entire software ecosystem.

Key benefits include:

Centralized Visibility: Eliminates the need to hunt through wikis, code repositories, or rely on "tribal knowledge."
Reduced Redundancy: Developers can easily check if a component already exists before building a new one.
Improved Collaboration: Creates shared awareness of available tools and best practices.
Faster Onboarding: New developers can quickly understand the available building blocks.

The catalog is populated through descriptor files (typically catalog-info.yaml) located alongside the component's source code. These files define the component's metadata and relationships.

# Example catalog-info.yaml for a Service Component
apiVersion: backstage.io/v1alpha1
kind: Component
metadata:
  name: user-service
  description: A backend service for managing user accounts.
  labels:
    team: user-management
    environment: production
  annotations:
    'backstage.io/kubernetes-id': 'user-service-prod'
    'prometheus.io/scrape': 'true'
    'prometheus.io/port': '8080'
spec:
  type: service
  lifecycle: production
  owner: group:user-management-team # Explicitly specifying kind: Group
  system: core-platform
  providesApis:
    - user-api
  consumesApis:
    - authentication-api
    - notification-service-api
  dependsOn:
    - resource:default/user-database # Explicitly specifying kind: Resource
    - component:default/authentication-service

‍

# Example catalog-info.yaml for a Library Component
apiVersion: backstage.io/v1alpha1
kind: Component
metadata:
  name: ui-toolkit
  description: A reusable UI toolkit for frontend applications.
  labels:
    language: javascript
    category: ui
  annotations:
    'github.com/project-slug': 'my-org/ui-toolkit'
spec:
  type: library
  lifecycle: stable
  owner: group:frontend-team
  system: shared-components

‍

# Example catalog-info.yaml for a Website Component
apiVersion: backstage.io/v1alpha1
kind: Component
metadata:
  name: marketing-website
  description: The public-facing marketing website.
  labels:
    environment: production
    platform: netlify
  annotations:
    'netlify.com/site-id': 'your-site-id'
    'backstage.io/source-location': 'url:https://github.com/my-org/marketing-website/tree/main'
spec:
  type: website
  lifecycle: production
  owner: group:marketing-team
  system: public-websites

These YAML files define crucial metadata like the component's kind (Component, API, Resource, etc.), metadata (name, description, ownership, links to external systems via annotations), and spec (type, lifecycle stage, relationships like dependsOn, providesApis, consumesApis).³³

2.2. Best Practices for Module Metadata

For the catalog to be truly effective, the metadata associated with each module must be comprehensive, consistent, and useful. Establishing clear standards for metadata is essential.

Populating these fields consistently, especially owner, description, type, lifecycle, tags, and documentation, dramatically improves a developer's ability to find the right module and understand how to use it. The owner field is particularly critical for accountability – knowing who to contact for questions or issues. Tags and labels enable powerful filtering and searching within the catalog UI.

2.3. Integrating Discoverability into Platform UIs

While a central catalog is foundational, discoverability shouldn't only live there. Integrating module information directly into the tools developers use daily significantly reduces friction and cognitive load.³⁴ Developers spend most of their time in IDEs and terminals; forcing them to constantly switch context to a separate portal just to find a module hinders productivity.³⁶

Consider these integration points:

Developer Portals (e.g., Backstage, Port): Provide the primary UI for browsing, searching, and viewing detailed module information surfaced from the catalog.³⁴
CLIs: Develop platform CLI commands that allow developers to query the catalog directly from their terminal.

Example: platform list-modules --type database --owner data-platform-team
Example: platform get-module-info user-auth-service --output yaml

IDE Plugins: Create plugins that suggest relevant internal libraries based on the code context, provide quick lookups for module documentation, or even scaffold code using standard modules.³⁴

The goal is to make finding and understanding internal modules a seamless part of the developer workflow, rather than a separate chore.³⁴

3. Documentation That Empowers Developers

Documentation is often an afterthought, yet it's critical for module adoption and effective use. Poor documentation leads to developer frustration, support overhead, and inhibits the reuse of standard components. Platform engineering teams must treat documentation as a first-class citizen.

3.1. Writing for Your Peers: Voice, Tone, and Technical Depth

Internal module documentation should be written by developers, for developers. This means:

Authentic Voice: Use a peer-to-peer tone. Avoid marketing fluff or overly formal language. Speak directly and technically.
Assume Technical Audience: Don't over-explain basic programming concepts, but clearly define module-specific terminology or complex logic.³⁷
Clarity and Conciseness: Use simple language where possible. Structure information logically with headings, lists, and code blocks. Get straight to the point.
Appropriate Technical Depth: Provide enough detail for developers to:

Understand the module's purpose and capabilities.
Integrate the module correctly.
Configure common options.
Troubleshoot frequent issues.
Understand architectural context (via diagrams).³⁸
Assess performance characteristics (via benchmarks, where relevant).

3.2. Essential Documentation Components

A comprehensive documentation set for an internal module typically includes:

README (README.md): The entry point. It should provide a high-level overview, installation instructions, basic usage examples, and links to more detailed documentation.³⁹

API Reference: Automatically generated documentation detailing classes, methods, functions, parameters, return types, and exceptions. Use standard tooling for your language.

Usage Examples: Go beyond basic syntax. Provide practical, runnable examples demonstrating how to solve common problems using the module.³⁷
Architecture Diagrams: Use simple diagrams (e.g., UML package diagrams, C4 context/container diagrams) to illustrate how the module fits into the larger system, its internal components, and its dependencies]. Example Concept: A diagram could show Service A calling the Standard Logging Library, which in turn interacts with a Log Aggregation Backend (like Splunk or ELK).
Changelogs (CHANGELOG.md): Maintain a chronological log of notable changes for each version, categorized by type (Added, Changed, Deprecated, Removed, Fixed, Security).

3.3. Measuring Documentation Effectiveness

Simply having documentation isn't enough; it needs to be effective. Traditional metrics like page views or general satisfaction surveys often fail to capture whether the documentation actually helped developers achieve their goals. High traffic to a specific doc page might even signal confusion or a product usability issue rather than documentation success.

A better approach focuses on outcomes and actionable feedback:

Task Completion Metrics: Track whether developers successfully complete tasks after consulting the documentation. Examples include:
- Time to first successful API call after reading API docs.
- Feature activation rates following documentation visits.
- Successful completion of key workflows (e.g., setting up a standard service) using guides.

Specific, Actionable Feedback: Embed targeted questions directly within the documentation pages, triggered after a user spends meaningful time there. Avoid vague questions like "Was this helpful?" Instead, ask:
- "Were you able to complete your task using this documentation? (Yes/No)"
- "If not, what specific information was missing or unclear?"
- "Which steps or concepts needed more clarity?"
- "Did you need to consult other resources (e.g., source code, colleagues)? Which ones?"

Content Effectiveness Scoring: Develop an internal rubric to periodically score major documentation sections based on key quality attributes:‍
- Findability: How easily can users locate specific information?‍
- Accuracy: Is the information technically correct and up-to-date?‍
- Completeness: Does it cover common use cases, parameters, and potential errors?‍
- Clarity: Is the language clear, concise, and unambiguous?‍
- Action Orientation: Does it directly enable task completion?

Qualitative Data: Supplement quantitative metrics with qualitative insights:
- Collect user stories about their documentation experience.
- Note specific phrases or questions developers use when asking for help related to documented features.
- Review support tickets or Slack channel discussions where documentation was mentioned or could have helped.

Measuring documentation effectiveness requires a shift from tracking output (number of pages written) to measuring outcomes (developer success, reduced friction, fewer support requests). This outcome-focused approach provides actionable data to prioritize improvements and demonstrate the value of high-quality documentation.

4. Versioning Internal Modules Like a Pro

Consistent and meaningful versioning is crucial for managing dependencies, communicating changes, and ensuring stability within the platform ecosystem. When versioning is done poorly or inconsistently, it leads to significant developer pain, broken builds, and a loss of trust.

4.1. Why Semantic Versioning (SemVer) Matters (and Its Challenges)

Semantic Versioning (SemVer) is the most widely adopted standard, using a MAJOR.MINOR.PATCH format (e.g., 1.2.3):

MAJOR (1.x.x -> 2.0.0): Incremented for incompatible API changes (breaking changes).
MINOR (1.2.x -> 1.3.0): Incremented for adding functionality in a backward-compatible manner.
PATCH (1.2.3 -> 1.2.4): Incremented for backward-compatible bug fixes.

Adhering to SemVer allows developers and dependency management tools to understand the potential impact of updating a module.⁴⁵ Tools can automatically update patch and minor versions (^1.2.3 or ~1.2.3 in package.json) with a reasonable degree of confidence that the update won't break their application.

The Pain of SemVer Violations: The biggest challenge arises when SemVer rules are violated, particularly when a breaking change is introduced in a MINOR or PATCH release. This completely undermines the trust model. Developers relying on automated updates suddenly find their builds failing or applications behaving unexpectedly after what should have been a safe update. This forces teams to pin exact versions, losing the benefit of automatic bug fixes and non-breaking features, or spend significant time debugging unexpected breakages.⁴⁷

Subtle Breaking Changes: Breaking changes aren't always obvious API signature modifications. They can be subtle:

Behavioral Changes: A function that previously returned null on error now throws an exception.
Performance Regressions: A minor update significantly increases latency, breaking downstream timeouts.
Dependency Changes: Updating a dependency that exposes its types in the module's public API can be breaking.
ABI Incompatibility: (Applicable in compiled languages like Java/C++) Changing internal implementation details might not break the source code API but can break binary compatibility, requiring recompilation of dependent code.
Serialization Format Changes: Changing the format of data persisted or sent over the wire, even if the API signature remains the same.

Conceptual Example of Subtle Break: A logging library v1.2.0 silently ignored None values passed to its log_metric function. In v1.2.1 (a patch release), it's changed to raise a TypeError for None values to enforce stricter input validation. While seemingly a bug fix, applications that previously relied on the tolerant behavior will now break unexpectedly after updating to v1.2.1. According to strict SemVer, this should have been a MAJOR version bump (or at least MINOR if the original behavior was considered a bug).

The strictness of SemVer presents a dilemma. Incrementing the MAJOR version for every tiny breaking change can lead to version number inflation (e.g., v17.0.0) which developers often perceive negatively, associating major bumps with significant effort. Conversely, holding back small breaking changes to bundle them into infrequent, large MAJOR releases creates significant migration pain for consumers when the major release finally drops. While automated tooling helps catch many explicit API breaks, human judgment is still required for subtle changes, and clear communication via changelogs is paramount.

4.2. Best Practices: Tagging, Automation, Changelogs

To implement versioning effectively for internal modules:

Use Git Tags: Mark releases with annotated Git tags (e.g., v1.2.3). Annotated tags store metadata like the tagger, date, and a message, making them suitable for official releases. Lightweight tags are simpler pointers and less ideal for formal versioning.⁴⁹

Bash
# Create an annotated tag
git tag -a v1.2.3 -m "Release version 1.2.3: Added feature X, fixed bug Y"

# Push the tag to the remote repository
git push origin v1.2.3

# Push all local tags to the remote repository
git push origin --tags

Automate Version Bumping: Use tools to manage version increments consistently.

bump2version (Python): Manually specify the part to bump (patch, minor, major). Updates version strings in configured files and can optionally commit and tag.⁵²

npm version (Node.js): Similar manual bumping for package.json.

semantic-release (Multi-language): Automatically determines the next version based on conventional commit messages (e.g., feat:, fix:, BREAKING CHANGE:) and handles publishing and changelog generation.

Maintain Changelogs: Keep a CHANGELOG.md file detailing user-facing changes for each version, categorized by type (Added, Changed, Deprecated, Removed, Fixed, Security). Follow conventions like Keep a Changelog. This provides essential context beyond the version number itself.

4.3. Enforcing SemVer Adherence

Maintaining SemVer discipline requires more than just good intentions. Automated checks are becoming essential:

SemVer Linting Tools: Tools like cargo-semver-checks (Rust) analyze the public API surface of a crate, compare it to a previous version (e.g., the latest published version), and report any changes that violate SemVer rules. Similar tools exist or are emerging for other ecosystems.

‍CI/CD Integration: Integrate SemVer checks into the CI/CD pipeline, typically before the publishing step. Fail the build if a violation is detected for the intended version bump (e.g., a breaking change detected for a minor version release).

Commit Message Linting: Enforce conventional commit message formats (e.g., using tools like commitlint) if using tools like semantic-release that rely on them.

Automated SemVer checking provides a critical safety net, especially for libraries consumed by many downstream projects. It catches violations before they are published, preventing widespread breakage and maintaining developer trust in the versioning scheme. This allows consumers to more confidently use version ranges (like ^1.2.3) for automatic updates.

5. Addressing Module Duplication and Consolidation

Module duplication is a common ailment in growing organizations. It leads to wasted development effort, increased maintenance burden, inconsistent user experiences, larger attack surfaces, and developer confusion.⁵³ Tackling duplication requires identifying redundant modules and implementing a clear consolidation strategy.

5.1. Identifying Redundancy: Causes and Detection

Duplication arises from both technical and organizational factors:

Technical Causes: Simple copy-pasting without refactoring ⁵⁵, insufficient abstraction or modular design leading to similar logic being implemented repeatedly, and poor code reuse practices.⁵⁵
Organizational Causes: Mergers and acquisitions bringing in overlapping systems ⁵³, internal reorganizations disrupting ownership ⁵³, weak governance or lack of enforced standards ³, poor cross-team communication leading to parallel development ²⁶, lack of visibility into existing modules (poor discoverability) ²³, "Not Invented Here" syndrome where teams prefer building their own solutions ⁶², and pressure to deliver features quickly over maintaining code health.⁵⁶

Detecting duplication involves multiple approaches:

Static Code Analysis (Copy/Paste Detection): Tools like PMD CPD and jscpd scan codebases for syntactically identical or similar code blocks-¹²⁰]. These are effective at finding direct copies but may miss functional overlap with different implementations.

# Example PMD CPD command
pmd cpd --minimum-tokens 75 --files /path/to/project/src --language java --format xml > cpd_report.xml

# Example jscpd command
jscpd --min-lines 5 --min-tokens 50 --pattern "**/*.js"./src --reporters console,html --output./report/

Manual Code Review: Necessary to identify semantic or functional duplication where the implementation differs, but the purpose is the same.55 This requires developers familiar with the domain.

Functional Overlap Analysis: Comparing the documented features, API signatures, or observed behavior of potentially redundant modules.64 This might involve creating feature matrices or using techniques borrowed from library science to compare metadata.⁶⁴

Platform Telemetry/Usage Analysis: If the platform collects metrics on module usage, analyzing this data can reveal if different teams are using distinct modules to accomplish similar tasks.

5.2. Consolidation Strategies: Making the Hard Choices

Once redundant modules are identified, a strategy for consolidation is needed.

Select the Standard: Use a decision matrix (refer back to Table 1 and criteria in Section 1.1) to objectively choose the best module to standardize on.¹⁰
Choose a Consolidation Approach:

Pick and Invest: Select the chosen standard module and invest in enhancing it to meet any missing requirements from the modules being retired. Decommission the others.⁵³ This is often less risky than building a completely new consolidated module.⁵³
Merge Functionality: Identify unique, valuable features from the redundant modules and incorporate them into the chosen standard module (or potentially a new, consolidated module).⁷¹ This requires careful integration.
Refactor and Abstract: Extract the common underlying logic from the duplicate modules into a new, shared core library. Refactor the original (now thinner) modules to depend on this core library]. This is suitable when duplicates share significant internal logic but have distinct interfaces or higher-level features.

Manage the Change: Consolidation involves migrating users off the old modules. This requires a clear change management plan, communication, and support (see Section 6).⁷⁴

Consolidation efforts often face resistance due to developer familiarity with existing tools or perceived migration costs. Platform teams must act like product managers, clearly articulating the benefits of consolidation—such as reduced maintenance overhead, improved stability, consistent behavior, and long-term cost savings—to gain buy-in from development teams. Demonstrating value is key to overcoming organizational inertia.⁷⁶

5.3. Measuring Consolidation Success

Success isn't just about reducing the number of modules. It's about achieving the intended benefits. Track KPIs that reflect these outcomes.

A balanced set of metrics helps demonstrate the tangible value of consolidation efforts, connecting technical cleanup activities to improvements in cost, stability, and developer productivity.

6. Managing Change: Migration and Deprecation

Introducing standard modules and consolidating duplicates inevitably means retiring older or non-standard components. This requires careful management of both migrating users to the new standards and gracefully deprecating the old ones.

6.1. Migrating Developers to Standard Modules

Simply declaring a module as "standard" isn't enough; platform teams need to actively help developers migrate.

Develop a Migration Playbook/Checklist: Create a reusable plan for migrating users from an old module to the new standard. Key steps include:

Assessment: Identify users/applications of the old module, analyze data/configuration differences.
Planning: Define target configuration, develop migration scripts/tooling, create a testing strategy (unit, integration, UAT), schedule the migration window(s), establish a rollback plan.
Execution: Perform the migration (potentially in phases).
Validation: Run tests, verify data/configuration, get user sign-off.
Post-Migration: Provide support, monitor performance, decommission old resources.

Communication and Support: Proactively communicate the migration plan, timeline, benefits, and potential impacts. Offer training sessions, clear documentation (including migration guides with code examples), and dedicated support channels.
Phased Rollouts: Consider migrating applications or teams incrementally rather than attempting a "big bang" migration, especially for widely used modules. This reduces risk and allows the platform team to gather feedback and refine the process.⁸⁰

6.2. Handling Outdated Modules: Risks and Motivation

Modules become outdated for various reasons (new versions released, underlying tech changes, better alternatives emerge). Continuing to use outdated modules introduces significant risks ⁸¹:

Security Vulnerabilities: Unpatched flaws are prime targets for attackers.²³
Compatibility Issues: May not work with newer OS versions, language runtimes, or other libraries.⁸¹
Lack of Support: Vendors or internal teams may no longer provide updates or bug fixes.⁸¹
Performance Degradation: Lack optimizations found in newer versions.⁸²
Compliance Failures: May not meet current regulatory or internal policy requirements.⁸²
Increased Maintenance Costs: Require workarounds or specialized knowledge.⁸¹
Technical Debt: Accumulate "interest" making future changes harder and riskier.⁸⁵

Despite these risks, developers may resist upgrading due to ⁴⁷:

Perceived cost/complexity of the upgrade.
Fear of introducing new bugs or breaking changes.
Lack of time or resources allocated for maintenance.
Complacency ("If it ain't broke, don't fix it").

Platform teams must actively manage the lifecycle of internal modules, making the risks of using outdated components visible and motivating upgrades by ⁸⁷:

Clearly communicating the risks associated with specific outdated versions.
Highlighting the benefits (new features, performance improvements, security fixes) of newer versions.
Providing smooth, well-documented migration paths.
Enforcing clear deprecation timelines.

Outdated modules are a significant source of hidden risk and technical debt. Proactive lifecycle management is essential for platform health and security.⁸¹

6.3. Graceful Deprecation: Policy and Execution

When a module needs to be retired, a formal deprecation process ensures users have adequate time and information to migrate, minimizing disruption.

Establish a Deprecation Policy: Define standard procedures ⁸⁸:‍
- Notice Period: Minimum time between deprecation announcement and removal (e.g., 6-12 months).‍
- Communication Channels: How deprecations will be announced.‍
- Support Level: Level of support provided during the deprecation period.‍
- Timeline: Clear dates for deprecation, end-of-support, and final removal.

Execute a Communication Plan: Use multiple channels to reach developers ¹⁰¹:‍
- Channels: Developer portal banners/notifications ⁹⁰, targeted emails ⁹⁰, documentation updates (see below) ⁹⁰, build/CLI warnings ¹⁰⁵, IDE notifications, release notes ⁴⁵, team chats (Slack/Teams), tech talks.¹⁰⁷‍
- Content: Announce clearly, state the reason(s), provide the full timeline, explain the impact, link to migration guides and alternatives, offer support contacts, and establish a feedback channel.^88
  ‍‍
In-Code Warnings: Mark deprecated code directly.

import warnings

def old_functionality(*args, **kwargs):
    warnings.warn(
        "old_functionality() is deprecated since v2.0 and will be removed in v3.0. "
        "Use new_functionality() instead. See [link-to-migration-guide]",
        DeprecationWarning,
        stacklevel=2
    )
    #... (optional: call new function or keep old logic)...

Implement Brownouts (Optional but Recommended): Schedule short, temporary periods where the deprecated module/API is intentionally made unavailable during the final "burnout" phase before removal. This forces developers to notice the deprecation and test their migration efforts. Communicate the brownout schedule clearly and provide informative error messages during the brownout period.

# Conceptual CLI Output During a Brownout
$ myapp --use-legacy-feature
WARNING: The --use-legacy-feature flag is deprecated and targets module 'legacy-auth' (scheduled for removal on 2025-12-31).
ERROR: Module 'legacy-auth' is temporarily unavailable due to a planned brownout (ends 16:00 UTC today).
Please migrate to the 'standard-auth-v2' module.
Migration Guide: [link-to-migration-guide]
For assistance, contact #platform-support.

6.4. Measuring Deprecation Success

Successful deprecation means users have migrated smoothly before the removal date. Metrics should track this transition:

Usage Monitoring: Track the number of calls or active users of the deprecated module over time using platform telemetry or logging. The goal is a clear downward trend towards zero.
Error Monitoring: Monitor for errors related to the deprecated module, especially "Deprecated Runtime/Feature" warnings or errors during brownouts. Spikes might indicate users hitting issues during migration attempts.
Support Channels: Analyze support tickets, Slack questions, or forum posts related to the deprecation. High volumes might indicate poor documentation or migration path issues.⁸⁹
Developer Surveys: After the migration period, survey developers about the clarity of communication, the ease of migration, and their satisfaction with the replacement module.

Simply removing code without ensuring users have successfully moved away risks breaking applications and damaging trust in the platform team.⁸⁹ Effective measurement focuses on the successful transition of users, minimizing disruption and validating the effectiveness of the communication and migration strategy.⁸⁹

7. Measuring Success: Platform Health and Developer Experience

Ultimately, effective internal module management should contribute to the overall goals of platform engineering: improving developer experience (DevEx) and accelerating software delivery. Measuring the impact of module management practices on these broader goals is crucial for demonstrating value and guiding future improvements.

7.1. Connecting Module Management to Key Metrics

Well-managed modules directly influence standard platform and engineering metrics:

DORA Metrics:

Deployment Frequency & Change Lead Time: Standardization via Golden Paths and reliable, well-documented modules streamline the path to production, reducing lead time and enabling more frequent deployments.
Change Failure Rate (CFR): Standardized, well-tested modules reduce the likelihood of deployments causing failures. Clear versioning prevents unexpected breaking changes.
Mean Time to Recovery (MTTR): Good documentation and reduced complexity from standardized modules help developers diagnose and fix issues faster when failures do occur.

SPACE Framework: Effective module management positively impacts several SPACE dimensions:

Satisfaction & Well-being: Reduced frustration from searching for modules, dealing with duplicates, or debugging poorly documented/versioned code.
Performance: Increased reliability and stability from using standardized, tested components.
Efficiency & Flow: Less time wasted on finding information, integrating complex/inconsistent modules, or fixing bugs caused by poor versioning. Reduced context switching.
Activity: Potentially reduces rework (lower bug rates, fewer retries due to breaking changes).

Developer Experience (DevEx) / Productivity: This is the overarching goal. Good module management contributes by:

Reducing Cognitive Load: Developers don't need to keep track of multiple similar modules or decipher complex, undocumented code.⁵⁸
Faster Onboarding: New developers can quickly find and use standard components.
Less Toil: Reduced time spent debugging integration issues, managing dependency conflicts, or searching for documentation.¹
Increased Satisfaction: Developers are happier when they can find what they need easily, integrate components smoothly, and trust the platform's building blocks.

7.2. Gauging Developer Satisfaction

Direct feedback from developers is invaluable for understanding the real-world impact of module management practices.

Feedback Loops: Establish regular channels for feedback, including surveys, one-on-one conversations with development teams, dedicated Slack channels, and potentially feedback widgets embedded in the developer portal or documentation.

Targeted Surveys: Ask specific questions related to the module lifecycle using rating scales (e.g., 1-5 Likert scale) and open-ended questions for qualitative insights.

Example Developer Survey Questions (Module Management Focus)

(Scale: 1 = Strongly Disagree, 5 = Strongly Agree)

Module Discovery & Usage:

I can easily find the internal modules/libraries I need for my tasks. (1-5)
The purpose and usage of standard internal modules are clear from their documentation/catalog entry. (1-5)
Integrating standard internal modules into my service is straightforward. (1-5)

Documentation:

4. The documentation for internal module was accurate and up-to-date. (1-5)

5. I was able to complete my task using the documentation for. (Yes/No/Partially)

6. The code examples provided in the documentation were helpful. (1-5)

Versioning & Updates:

7. The versioning scheme for internal modules clearly communicates the impact of updates. (1-5)

8. I feel confident updating to new minor/patch versions of standard internal modules. (1-5)

9. Communication about module deprecations (timeline, reasons, alternatives) is clear and timely. (1-5)

Open Feedback:

10. What is the biggest challenge you face when working with internal modules/libraries?

11. How could the platform team improve the documentation or discoverability of internal modules?

12. Do you have any feedback on the recent migration/deprecation of?

7.3. Connecting to Business Value

While technical metrics and developer satisfaction are important, platform teams must also articulate how their work impacts broader business goals. This involves translating technical improvements into business outcomes.

Translation: Map technical metrics to business value. For example:

Improved Dev Velocity (lower Cycle Time, higher Deployment Frequency) -> Faster Time-to-Market.
Improved Stability (lower CFR, lower MTTR, fewer incidents) -> Higher Product Reliability, Better Customer Satisfaction.
Reduced Maintenance/Toil (via consolidation, automation) -> Lower Operational Costs, More Engineering Capacity for Features.
Higher Developer Satisfaction -> Improved Developer Retention, Lower Hiring Costs.

Investment Profile: Use visualizations (like investment profiles) to show how platform improvements (e.g., standardization reducing rework) shift engineering effort from maintenance and bug fixing towards building new, value-creating features.

Demonstrating this connection is crucial for securing ongoing investment and buy-in for platform engineering initiatives. Reporting should focus on how technical improvements directly enable the business to move faster, operate more reliably, and innovate more effectively.

8. Conclusion: Building a Sustainable Module Ecosystem

Managing internal software modules effectively is not a side task for platform engineers; it's a core responsibility that underpins developer productivity, platform stability, and the overall speed of innovation. Taming the module jungle requires a multi-faceted approach encompassing:

Intentional Standardization: Defining and promoting clear standards and Golden Paths.
Proactive Governance: Shifting from manual gatekeeping to automated enforcement and enablement.
Enhanced Discoverability: Implementing service catalogs and embedding discovery into developer workflows.
Empowering Documentation: Creating clear, concise, and actionable documentation tailored to developers.
Robust Versioning: Adhering to SemVer, automating checks, and maintaining clear changelogs.
Strategic Consolidation: Identifying and addressing redundancy through objective evaluation and planned migration.
Graceful Deprecation: Managing the end-of-life for modules with clear communication and support.
Continuous Measurement: Tracking metrics related to both platform health and developer experience, and connecting them to business value.

This is not a one-time effort but a continuous cycle of improvement. Platform teams must treat their internal modules and the surrounding tooling as products, constantly gathering feedback, monitoring usage, iterating on standards, and refining processes. By investing in a well-managed, discoverable, and reliable internal module ecosystem, platform engineering teams lay a critical foundation for accelerating development and enabling their organizations to thrive.

Works cited

Scaling Securely: How Platform Engineering Supports Developer ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.synextra.co.uk/knowledge-base/platform-engineering-velocity/
Developing modular software: Top strategies and best practices - vFunction, accessed May 7, 2025, https://vfunction.com/blog/modular-software/
Success factor platform and module strategy - CO Improve, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.co-improve.com/en/performance-improvement-rundd/align-the-strategy/platform-and-module-strategy.html
Transformation to platform engineering: Practical steps, benefits and case study - CodiLime, accessed May 7, 2025, https://codilime.com/blog/platform-engineering-before-you-start/
Software Development Standards: Best Practices and Strategic Considerations in ... - Pulsion Technology, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.pulsion.co.uk/blog/software-development-standards/
Platform Engineering | Humanitec, accessed May 7, 2025, https://humanitec.com/platform-engineering
Development Velocity: Why It Should Be Your Core Focus - Kyle David Group, accessed May 7, 2025, https://kyledavidgroup.com/articles/development-velocity/
The Software Selection Process | Olive Technologies, accessed May 7, 2025, https://olive.app/blog/the-software-selection-process/
ERP Selection Process - Guide On ERP Software Selection Criteria - Panorama Consulting, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.panorama-consulting.com/erp-software-selection-guide/
Decision Matrix for Software Development Teams - Lark, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.larksuite.com/en_us/topics/project-management-methodologies-for-functional-teams/decision-matrix-for-software-development-teams
Decision Matrix Template | Confluence - Atlassian, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.atlassian.com/software/confluence/resources/guides/how-to/decision-matrix
What is a Decision Matrix? Pugh, Problem, or Selection Grid - ASQ, accessed May 7, 2025, https://asq.org/quality-resources/decision-matrix
What is a Decision Matrix, and How Can We Use it? - Simplilearn.com, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.simplilearn.com/what-is-decision-matrix-how-to-use-article
Software Selection Process and Criteria - National Neighborhood Indicators Partnership, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.neighborhoodindicators.org/sites/default/files/publications/SoftwareSelectionProcessCriteria.pdf
7 Quick Steps to Create a Decision Matrix, with Examples [2025] - Asana, accessed May 7, 2025, https://asana.com/resources/decision-matrix-examples
What is a Framework in Programming and Engineering? - AWS, accessed May 7, 2025, https://aws.amazon.com/what-is/framework/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.leadingagile.com/2018/10/decision-matrix/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/weighted-decision-matrix/
Designing Golden Paths - Red Hat, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/designing-golden-paths
What is a Golden Path for software development? - Red Hat, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.redhat.com/en/topics/devops/golden-paths
The Case for Abstractions in IaC - Massdriver, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.massdriver.cloud/blogs/the-case-for-abstractions-in-iac
How Platform Engineering Impacts Infrastructure Automation - DZone, accessed May 7, 2025, https://dzone.com/articles/platform-engineering-impacts-infrastructure-automation
Today's Lack of Software Visibility and the Implications - NetRise, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.netrise.io/xiot-security-blog/todays-lack-of-software-visibility-and-the-implications
The Detrimental Effects of Inadequate IT Visibility on Your Business - Toonimo, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.toonimo.com/post/the-detrimental-effects-of-inadequate-it-visibility-on-your-business
Avoid duplicate module imports - Datadog Docs, accessed May 7, 2025, https://docs.datadoghq.com/security/code_security/static_analysis/static_analysis_rules/javascript-code-style/no-duplicate-imports/
Common communication breakdowns | Mentally Healthy Workplaces, accessed May 7, 2025, https://beta.mentallyhealthyworkplaces.gov.au/explore-modules/mentally-healthy-policy-and-practice/communication-and-feedback/common
Communication Breakdown | PDF - Scribd, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.scribd.com/document/621476873/COMMUNICATION-BREAKDOWN
Everything you need to know about Open Policy Agent (OPA) and Terraform - Scalr, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.scalr.com/blog/everything-you-need-to-know-about-open-policy-agent-opa-and-terraform
Terraform - Open Policy Agent, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.openpolicyagent.org/docs/latest/terraform/
Navigating the Pitfalls of Internal Developer Portals: What You Need to Know - Harness, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.harness.io/blog/navigating-the-pitfalls-of-internal-developer-portals-what-you-need-to-know
Do's and don'ts when build an internal developer platform - Kubiya, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.kubiya.ai/resource-post/do-and-don-t-when-build-an-internal-developer-platform
Leveraging Modularity to Drive Innovation in Software Development - Number Analytics, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.numberanalytics.com/blog/leveraging-modularity-software-development-innovation
Descriptor Format of Catalog Entities | Backstage Software Catalog and Developer Platform, accessed May 7, 2025, https://backstage.io/docs/features/software-catalog/descriptor-format/
Best Practices for Building an Internal Developer Platform ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://cloudomation.com/cloudomation-blog/best-practices-for-building-an-internal-developer-platform/
How to Choose the Right Tools for Your Internal Developer Platform, accessed May 7, 2025, https://deploy.equinix.com/blog/platform-engineering-choosing-tools-for-your-idp-internal-developer-platform/
What Is Platform Engineering? A Guide for Modern Teams | LinearB Blog, accessed May 7, 2025, https://linearb.io/blog/platform-engineering
knowledgSoftware Documentation Best Practices [With Examples], accessed May 7, 2025, https://helpjuice.com/blog/software-documentation
Software Design Document [Tips & Best Practices] | The Workstream, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.atlassian.com/work-management/knowledge-sharing/documentation/software-design-document
RichardLitt/standard-readme: A standard style for README ... - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/RichardLitt/standard-readme
README.md template | Documenting your project - Drupal, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.drupal.org/docs/develop/managing-a-drupalorg-theme-module-or-distribution-project/documenting-your-project/readmemd-template
README.md template | Documenting your project | Drupal Wiki ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.drupal.org/docs/develop/documenting-your-project/readme-template
cimarieta/sphinx-autodoc-example: Tutorial about how to use sphinx to automatically generate documentation - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/cimarieta/sphinx-autodoc-example
Automatic documentation generation from code - Sphinx, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.sphinx-doc.org/en/master/tutorial/automatic-doc-generation.html
sphinx.ext.autodoc – Include documentation from docstrings ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.sphinx-doc.org/en/master/usage/extensions/autodoc.html
Best Practices of Versioning in Software Engineering - Qodo, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.qodo.ai/blog/best-practices-of-versioning-in-software-engineering/
Software Versioning Best Practices: Creating an Effective System - Thales CPL, accessed May 7, 2025, https://cpl.thalesgroup.com/software-monetization/software-versioning-basics
Software Dependency Management: A Complete Guide, accessed May 7, 2025, https://blog.codacy.com/software-dependency-management
devDependency Status. Dependencies Status - david-dm.org, accessed May 7, 2025, https://david-dm.org/jaredhanson/passport-google-oauth
git tag | Atlassian Git Tutorial, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.atlassian.com/git/tutorials/inspecting-a-repository/git-tag
How to Use Git Tags for Versioning Releases: A Comprehensive Guide - AlgoCademy, accessed May 7, 2025, https://algocademy.com/blog/how-to-use-git-tags-for-versioning-releases-a-comprehensive-guide/
Git Tags: Streamlining Your Version Control Workflow, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.lucentinnovation.com/blogs/technology-posts/master-git-project-history-the-comprehensive-guide-to-git-tags
c4urself/bump2version: Version-bump your software with a ... - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/c4urself/bump2version
Strategies for eliminating duplication within IT | The Enterprisers ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://enterprisersproject.com/article/2016/2/strategies-eliminating-duplication-within-it
Data Duplication Dilemma: Strategies for Minimizing Redundancy - Susco Solutions, accessed May 7, 2025, https://suscosolutions.com/strategies-for-minimizing-data-redundancy/
Avoid Duplicated Code in Software Development - SkillReactor Blog, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.skillreactor.io/blog/duplicated-code/
Code Duplication: Best Practices for Maintainable Programming - Metridev, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.metridev.com/metrics/code-duplication-best-practices-for-maintainable-programming/
Duplication Bug - Glossary - DevX, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.devx.com/terms/duplication-bug/
What Is Cognitive Load in Software Development? - HAY, accessed May 7, 2025, https://blog.howareyou.work/what-is-cognitive-load-software-development/
Reduce Cognitive Load in Software Engineering through Platform Engineering, accessed May 7, 2025, https://dev.to/seal-io/reduce-cognitive-load-in-software-engineering-through-platform-engineering-4176
What is SKU Proliferation? - DealHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://dealhub.io/glossary/sku-proliferation/
Is a common library a good idea? - Software Engineering Stack Exchange, accessed May 7, 2025, https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/339276/is-a-common-library-a-good-idea
Platform Engineering: Patterns and anti-patterns | StackSpot AI, accessed May 7, 2025, https://stackspot.com/en/blog/platform-engineering-mastering-patterns
Standards in software development and 9 best practices - OpsLevel, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.opslevel.com/resources/standards-in-software-development-and-9-best-practices
Overlap Analysis - SPARC, accessed May 7, 2025, https://sparcopen.org/our-work/negotiation-resources/data-analysis/overlap-analysis/
Detection of Functional Overlapping Genes: Simulation and Case Studies - PMC, accessed May 7, 2025, https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2972474/
Designing with Redundancy: Improving Reliability in Critical Systems, accessed May 7, 2025, https://runtimerec.com/designing-with-redundancy-improving-reliability-in-critical-systems/
Redundancy (engineering) - Wikipedia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redundancy_(engineering)
accessed January 1, 1970, https://softwareengineering.stackexchange.com/questions/260003/how-to-identify-and-remove-redundant-code-and-functionality
Duplicate cases - Pega Academy, accessed May 7, 2025, https://academy.pega.com/topic/duplicate-cases/v1
Redwood Experience: Candidate Duplicate Check - Oracle Help Center, accessed May 7, 2025, https://docs.oracle.com/en/cloud/saas/readiness/hcm/25b/recr-25b/25B-recruiting-wn-f37004.htm
Data Consolidation: Best Practices, Strategies & Tools - Kanerika, accessed May 7, 2025, https://kanerika.com/blogs/data-consolidation/
Package Diagram – Unified Modeling Language (UML) - GeeksforGeeks, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/package-diagram-introduction-elements-use-cases-and-benefits/
Merge Modules, accessed May 7, 2025, https://docs.revenera.com/installanywhere2020/Content/helplibrary/ia_mergemodules.htm
6 Change Management Tips for ERP Implementation - NetSuite, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.netsuite.com/portal/resource/articles/erp/erp-change-management.shtml
18+ Best Change Management Tools for Your Business - Spekit, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.spekit.com/blog/change-management-tools
Guide to Standardized Process: Best Practices for 2024 - Helpjuice, accessed May 7, 2025, https://helpjuice.com/blog/process-standardization
Why Platform Consolidation Matters: How to Simplify Your Tech Stack - Zylo, accessed May 7, 2025, https://zylo.com/blog/platform-consolidation/
Ensure Platform Engineering Success With These Expert Tips - Forbes, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbestechcouncil/2025/01/14/ensure-platform-engineering-success-with-these-expert-tips/
The Kubernetes API, accessed May 7, 2025, https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/overview/kubernetes-api/
How to Plan for a Software Migration: Best Practices - Whatfix, accessed May 7, 2025, https://whatfix.com/blog/software-migration/
The High Cost of Doing Nothing: How Legacy Systems Leave ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://springbrooksoftware.com/the-high-cost-of-doing-nothing-how-legacy-systems-leave-governments-exposed-outdated-software-cybersecurity/
Outdated Software - Plurilock, accessed May 7, 2025, https://plurilock.com/deep-dive/outdated-software/
Risks and Mitigation of Unpatched Software: The Not-So-Hidden ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.tanium.com/blog/risks-and-mitigation-of-unpatched-software/
How to mitigate the risks of outdated BAS hardware, software and tools | Johnson Controls, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.johnsoncontrols.com/insights/2024/feature-story/how-to-mitigate-the-risks-of-outdated-bas-hardware-software-and-tools
The complete guide to technical debt management: best practices ..., accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.rst.software/blog/technical-debt-management
Addressing Technical Debt in Expansive Software Projects - Qt, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.qt.io/quality-assurance/blog/adressing-technical-debt
Case Studies: Three customer platform engineering implementations | Microsoft Learn, accessed May 7, 2025, https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/platform-engineering/case-study
How to deprecate | Core change policies | About guide on Drupal.org, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.drupal.org/about/core/policies/core-change-policies/how-to-deprecate
Package Deprecation Policy: Best Practices and Graceful Transitions, accessed May 7, 2025, https://json-server.dev/deprecation-package-policy/
Best Practices for Deprecating an API Without Alienating Your Users - Treblle Blog, accessed May 7, 2025, https://blog.treblle.com/best-practices-deprecating-api/
Managing breaking changes | Make Developer Hub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://developers.make.com/custom-apps-documentation/updating-your-app/approved-apps/managing-breaking-changes
Effective Strategies for Managing API Versioning and Deprecation | MoldStud, accessed May 7, 2025, https://moldstud.com/articles/p-managing-api-versioning-and-deprecation
Deprecation best practices - PyAnsys developer's guide, accessed May 7, 2025, https://dev.docs.pyansys.com/coding-style/deprecation.html
Showing or Marking Deprecating APIs in Developer Portal | API Connect, accessed May 7, 2025, https://community.ibm.com/community/user/discussion/showing-or-marking-deprecating-apis-in-developer-portal
Deprecation - Meraki Dashboard API v1 - Cisco DevNet, accessed May 7, 2025, https://developer.cisco.com/meraki/api-v1/deprecation/
API Deprecation Checklist - CheckOps, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.checkops.com/api-deprecation-checklist/
On writing for deprecation - Slack Design, accessed May 7, 2025, https://slack.design/articles/on-writing-for-deprecation/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://blog.treblle.com/best-practices-deprecating-api-without-alienating-your-users/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://nordicapis.com/communicating-api-deprecation/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.make.com/en/blog/managing-breaking-changes-in-software-development
accessed January 1, 1970, https://apifriends.com/api-management/api-deprecation-communication-plan/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/effective-api-deprecation-communication-plan- چارلی-li-ph-d-
accessed January 1, 1970, https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/azure/architecture/guide/api-design/deprecation
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.redhat.com/en/blog/red-hats-api-deprecation-policy-and-communication-plan
"This cli will be deprecated soon. Use new server cli" seen on 2951 Router, accessed May 7, 2025, https://community.cisco.com/t5/switching/quot-this-cli-will-be-deprecated-soon-use-new-server-cli-quot/td-p/2932804
NPM warn message about deprecated package - Stack Overflow, accessed May 7, 2025, https://stackoverflow.com/questions/35236735/npm-warn-message-about-deprecated-package
Stop Building Internal Tools Nobody Wants: A Platform Engineer's Guide - Ran The Builder, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.ranthebuilder.cloud/post/platform-engineering-internal-tools-adoption-guide
5 KPIs for internal product managers to track - Pendo Blog, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.pendo.io/pendo-blog/5-kpis-for-internal-product-managers-to-track/
Metrics — vLLM, accessed May 7, 2025, https://docs.vllm.ai/en/v0.8.2/design/v1/metrics.html
Platform Engineering: measuring your success - Xebia, accessed May 7, 2025, https://xebia.com/blog/platform-engineering-measuring-your-success/
Platform Engineering Metrics & KPIs to Measure Whether or Not Your Platform is Working, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.puppet.com/blog/platform-engineering-metrics
Understanding Platform Engineering Metrics for Improved Team Performance - Multitudes, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.multitudes.com/blog/platform-engineering-metrics
Check NPM Version | Essential Update and Manage Guide - IOFLOOD.com, accessed May 7, 2025, https://ioflood.com/blog/npm-version/
Commonly Used NPM Commands - Web Reference, accessed May 7, 2025, https://webreference.com/cheat-sheets/npm/
cargo-semver-checks - crates.io: Rust Package Registry, accessed May 7, 2025, https://crates.io/crates/cargo-semver-checks
SemVer in Rust: Tooling, Breakage, and Edge Cases — FOSDEM 2024, accessed May 7, 2025, https://predr.ag/blog/semver-in-rust-tooling-breakage-and-edge-cases/
cargo-semver-checks - crates.io: Rust Package Registry, accessed May 7, 2025, https://crates.io/crates/cargo-semver-checks/0.27.0
pmd:cpd - Plugins - Apache Maven, accessed May 7, 2025, https://maven.apache.org/plugins/maven-pmd-plugin/cpd-mojo.html
Using CPD/PMD on the command line - Stack Overflow, accessed May 7, 2025, https://stackoverflow.com/questions/28941048/using-cpd-pmd-on-the-command-line
pmd/docs/pages/pmd/userdocs/cpd/cpd.md at main - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/pmd/pmd/blob/main/docs/pages/pmd/userdocs/cpd/cpd.md
pmd/docs/pages/pmd/userdocs/installation.md at main - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/pmd/pmd/blob/master/docs/pages/pmd/userdocs/installation.md
@jscpd/finder | Yarn, accessed May 7, 2025, https://classic.yarnpkg.com/en/package/@jscpd/finder
jscpd - UNPKG, accessed May 7, 2025, https://app.unpkg.com/jscpd@1.0.2/files/README.md
kucherenko/jscpd: Copy/paste detector for programming ... - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/kucherenko/jscpd
kucherenko/jscpd: Copy/paste detector for programming ... - GitHub, accessed May 7, 2025, https://github.com/kucherenko/jscpd#usage-cli
How to Measure Internal Communications [Key Metrics Included] - Haiilo Blog, accessed May 7, 2025, https://blog.haiilo.com/blog/how-to-measure-internal-communication-ic-best-practices-examples/
6 Ideas to Measure Your Key Internal Communication Metrics - Staffbase, accessed May 7, 2025, https://staffbase.com/blog/measure-internal-communications/
Measure Modularity – KPIs for Successful Product Platforms, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.modularmanagement.com/blog/measure-modularity-kpi-for-successful-product-platforms
10 KPIs for the digital workplace | Pendo.io, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.pendo.io/resources/10-kpis-for-the-digital-workplace/
accessed January 1, 1970, https://www.harness.io/blog/platform-engineering-metrics
accessed January 1, 1970, https://getdx.com/guides/platform-engineering/measuring-platform-success-metrics-and-kpis/
How to capture Python runtime warnings - LabEx, accessed May 7, 2025, https://labex.io/tutorials/python-how-to-capture-python-runtime-warnings-425664
Warnings in Python | GeeksforGeeks, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.geeksforgeeks.org/warnings-in-python/
Approaches to Deprecating Code in JavaScript | CSS-Tricks, accessed May 7, 2025, https://css-tricks.com/approaches-to-deprecating-code-in-javascript/
console: warn() static method - Web APIs | MDN, accessed May 7, 2025, https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/console/warn_static
What is Code Refactoring Examples, Techniques, Tools, and Best Practices - ISHIR, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.ishir.com/blog/110196/what-is-code-refactoring-examples-techniques-tools-and-best-practices.htm
cpd-cli command reference - IBM, accessed May 7, 2025, https://www.ibm.com/docs/en/software-hub/5.1.x?topic=cpd-cli-command-reference
https://pmd.github.io/latest/pmd_userdocs_cpd.html
https://pmd.github.io/pmd-6.55.0/pmd_userdocs_cpd.html

‍